Obverse 5 is identified by a die scratch through the upper lip of Miss
Liberty and date placement at LE with digit punch matrix repunching
that features initial impressions to the south below the serif of the first
1, within the upper loop of the 8, below the flag of the 7 and below
the serif of the second 1.
Type II Reverse D develops the following die cracks: 1. Die crack from the rim at 12:30 to the shield. 2. Die crack from the rim at 2:00 downward through the right wreath.
Comments: The digit punch
matrix repunching of Obverse 5 is the result of digits being impressed
into the digit punch matrix twice and is not date repunching into the
working die. Since the repunching is found on the digit punch,
the doubling on the date will appear on multiple obverses in 1871.
Plate coin:
Images courtesy of Rick Snow of Eagle Eye Rare Coins, PCGS AU58 (PS)